Hiring Guides

How to Check If an IT Company's Reviews Are Genuine

How to check if an IT company's reviews are genuine: cross-check platforms, confirm reviewers, spot suspicious patterns, test the work and run useful reference calls.

How to Check If an IT Company's Reviews Are Genuine

To check whether an IT company's reviews are genuine, compare them across several independent platforms, confirm that reviewers are real people at real companies, look for suspicious patterns in timing, wording and ratings, and check that the projects described match the company's size and services. Then ask for references and speak to them yourself, with your own questions. Reviews are a starting point for a shortlist, not proof. This guide shows how to test each review signal, what review platforms do and do not verify, and how to run reference calls that reveal more than a five-star rating.

Why IT company reviews need checking

Buying software development, IT support or digital services is high value and hard to judge in advance, so reviews carry a lot of weight. That also makes them worth manipulating. Common problems include reviews written by friends or staff, reviews of small or unrelated jobs presented as major projects, reviews copied across platforms, and negative feedback that has been suppressed or buried.

Regulators take this seriously. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission announced a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials on 14 August 2024. According to the FTC's questions and answers on the rule, it took effect on 21 October 2024. It prohibits, among other things, reviews from people who do not exist or have no real experience with the business, paying for reviews that must be positive or negative, undisclosed reviews from company insiders, and suppressing negative reviews through threats or intimidation. The rule is written around consumer reviews, and the FTC's guidance does not address business-to-business reviews directly. Still, its categories are a useful checklist of the tricks to watch for, wherever the company is based.

Know what each platform actually verifies

Review platforms differ in how much checking they do, and a "verified" label can mean different things. Before relying on any platform, read its own explanation. For example, Software Advice explains in how it verifies reviews that moderators check reviewer identity, look for conflicts of interest and AI-generated personas, run manual and automated content checks, and request extra proof of use when a review is flagged. Clutch shows a verification status and the review method on each review on a company profile, so you can see whether a review came from an interview or another route.

Question to ask about a platformWhy it matters
How is the reviewer's identity checked?Identity checks make fake reviewer accounts harder to create
Is the client relationship confirmed, for example by contacting the client?A real person may still never have worked with the company
Can the company choose which clients are invited?Most platforms rely on companies inviting clients, so expect a positive bias
Can the company remove or hide reviews?Removal rights change how far you can trust the average rating
Does payment affect placement or the display of reviews?Sponsored positions are not the same as review-based rankings

Trusted IT Firms publishes its own verification process and ranking methodology, so you can see what a listing on this site has and has not been checked for. Read those pages the same way you would read any other platform's: as a description of specific checks, not a guarantee about a company's work. No directory can confirm every detail of every project, which is why the steps below still matter. For a wider comparison, see how B2B directory reviews and rankings work.

Step 1: Cross-check reviews across platforms

Look the company up on several independent sources: B2B directories, Google reviews for its office, app store listings for apps it built, and professional networks. Then compare:

  • Consistency: broadly similar ratings and themes across sites suggest a real pattern. A perfect score on one platform and complaints everywhere else deserves questions.
  • Duplication: the same review text appearing on several platforms under different names is a warning sign.
  • Volume against size: a company with a small team and a short history claiming hundreds of large projects needs explaining.
  • Testimonials on the company's own site: these are chosen by the company. Treat them as marketing unless they can be traced to a named person you can find elsewhere.

Step 2: Check that reviewers are real

For the reviews that most influence your decision, usually the most detailed and most recent ones, check the reviewer:

  1. Does the reviewer's company exist, with a website and a public footprint?
  2. Can you find the person on a professional network in the role stated in the review?
  3. Was that person at that company at the time of the project?
  4. Is the reviewer's company plausibly a client, or is it a partner, reseller or related business?
  5. Does the reviewer appear to work for, or be related to, the company being reviewed?

You do not need to check every review. Five or six careful checks on the reviews that matter most tell you a lot about the rest.

Step 3: Look for patterns that suggest manipulation

PatternWhat it can meanHow to check
Bursts of reviews in a few days, then silenceA review drive or purchased reviewsLook at review dates and compare with the company's history
Very similar wording, structure or phrasesReviews written by one person or from a templateRead several reviews side by side
Praise with no specificsThe reviewer may not know the projectLook for named technologies, timelines and problems solved
Only perfect scoresSelection bias or removed negativesSearch other platforms for mixed feedback
Projects unrelated to the company's servicesReviews from a different business or small favoursCompare with services listed on the profile
Hostile responses to critical reviewsPossible pressure on reviewersRead how the company replies to complaints

A few genuine critical reviews are not a bad sign. Every company that has done real work has had projects that went less well. What matters is whether problems repeat and how the company responded. A calm, specific reply that explains what changed is often more reassuring than a page of perfect scores.

Step 4: Test the work behind the reviews

Reviews describe projects, and projects can often be checked directly. A guide from PerfectionGeeks on verifying app development company reviews suggests confirming that portfolio apps are live in app stores. Go further:

  • Open the live websites and apps mentioned. Are they still running, and do they match the description?
  • Check app store listings: the developer or seller name, update history and user ratings.
  • Ask which parts of a showcased project the company actually built. Many projects involve several suppliers.
  • Ask for a short walkthrough of a relevant project by someone who worked on it.

Step 5: Run reference calls that reveal something

References chosen by the company will usually be positive, but the right questions still produce useful detail. Ask for two or three references from projects similar to yours in size and type, and ideally one from a project that ran into difficulties. Then ask:

  1. What was the project, what did it cost roughly and how long did it take compared with the plan?
  2. Who from the company did you work with day to day? Are they still there?
  3. What went wrong, and how did the company handle it?
  4. How accurate were their estimates and status reports?
  5. Did you receive the code, documentation and credentials at the end?
  6. Would you hire them again for the same kind of work? For a different kind?

Listen for specifics and hesitation. "They were great" is less useful than a story about a missed deadline that was recovered honestly. Our list of questions to ask a software development company can help you plan the rest of the evaluation.

Red flags that should stop the process

  • The company offers you a discount or other benefit in exchange for a positive review later.
  • Reviewers turn out to be employees, relatives or partners with no disclosure.
  • The company refuses to provide any references, or only offers references you cannot reach.
  • Portfolio projects cannot be found or were clearly built by someone else.
  • Critical reviews have been answered with threats or accusations.

Our article on red flags when hiring an IT service provider covers warning signs beyond reviews, from vague proposals to unclear contracts.

Use reviews well, and add your own

Treat reviews as one input alongside proposals, technical conversations, references and a small paid starting phase. Once you have worked with a company, add to the evidence for the next buyer: you can write a review on Trusted IT Firms describing the project, what went well and what did not. When you are ready to build a shortlist, browse all companies and apply the checks above to each one.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if an IT company review is fake?

Check that the reviewer and their company exist, look for bursts of reviews, repeated wording and praise with no specifics, and compare ratings across independent platforms.

Are fake reviews illegal?

In the United States, the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials took effect on 21 October 2024 and bans fake reviews, undisclosed insider reviews and review suppression. Its guidance is written around consumer reviews, so take advice for business-to-business situations.

Does a verified badge mean a company is good?

No. A badge means a platform checked specific things. Read the platform's verification page to see what was checked, and still review the work and speak to references.

How many references should I ask for?

Two or three from projects similar to yours, ideally including one project that ran into difficulties, so you can hear how problems were handled.

Sources

Add Trusted IT Firms to your preferred sources

Add trusteditfirms.com as a preferred source on Google, or open this page in your AI assistant to use it as a source.

· Trusted IT Firms Team

The Trusted IT Firms editorial team writes guides to finding and working with IT companies.

Keep reading

List your IT company for free

Create a profile in minutes, get reviewed by our editors and start receiving enquiries from clients looking for your skills.